Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 88%
Practice
A nurse working in a hospital administers a medication to the wrong client and is sued by the client. Under contract law, which liability occurs when the hospital is additionally identified as a defendant in the legal action? Select one that does not apply
Correct answer
B
Rationale
Rationale A: Vicarious liability applies in this situation. Vicarious liability applies when accountability for a wrong is assigned to a person or entity that did not directly cause an injury but has a contractual relationship with the person who did cause the wrong. The nurse is still liable for his or her own actions. Rationale B: A borrowed servant does not apply to this situation. A borrowed servant applies when an employer directs a nurse to work for a second employer (e.g., agency nurse); the second employer is held accountable for the nurse's actions. Rationale C: The liability of Captain of the ship applies in this situation. The liability of Captain of the ship occurs when a health-care provider is held liable for a nurse who is working under the direction of the health-care provider. The nurse is still liable for his or her own actions. Rationale D: Respondeat superior refers to 'Let the master answer' and applies in this situation. When an agency hires a nurse, the nurse functions as a representative of the institution and must perform within its policies and procedures; the hospital is responsible for the actions of the nurse. The nurse is still liable for his or her own actions. [Inferred for Choice E: Quasi-intentional tort is not related to this situation. An example of a quasi-intentional tort is making false statements, verbally (slander) or in writing (libel), about another person that harm the person's reputation (defamation of character) or holds the person up to ridicule or contempt.]