Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 64%
Practice
Your patient has just recently been diagnosed with familial adenomatous polyposis (FAP). This disorder is chronic, progressive, and fatal. There is a genetic test that can tell whether children of parents with the disease will develop it. The test is very accurate. The patient has become divorced and refuses to give you his consent to inform his ex-wife who now has custody of their three children. He threatens to sue you if you reveal elements of his medical care to his ex-wife. What should you do?
Correct answer
D
Rationale
The patient's right to confidentiality ends where it comes into conflict with the safety of other people. The right to confidentiality is extremely strong, but it is not universal and absolute. In this case, the children of the patient have a right to know whether their lives will be cut short by the disease of familial adenomatous polyposis (FAP) and colon cancer. The most important element is that screening for polyps should begin at the age of 12 with screening sigmoidoscopy every year. Colectomy needs to be done if polyps are found. Hence, in FAP there is a very specific intervention that can prevent colon cancer and a very specific screening that can be done. In addition, the mother has a right to know whether her children will become ill and how to plan for that. If a child falls and breaks his leg, one parent cannot claim confidentiality as a reason to withhold this critical health information from the other parent. As a part of divorce, the stipulation that each parent must inform the other parent of health-care issues for the children as they arise is a standard part of the agreement. Although, in this case, the health-care issue involves the private health of one parent, the issue is still pertinent to the other parent as the caregiver of the children. The right to one person's to privacy is not as important as the right of another person to safety. This is established standard and does not require a court order. You will have more liability from the mother of the children if she is NOT informed than from violating the confidentiality of the patient to inform. She can successfully pursue a legal action stating you, the physician, did not inform her that her children were at risk of the 'injury' of the genetic disease. The health department does not do notification for genetic diseases. The health department notifies partners and the population at risk of transmissible diseases such as tuberculosis, HIV, STDs, and food- or water-borne diseases.