Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 64%
Practice
You are on-scene with a patient in cardiac arrest. You turn the monitor/defibrillator on and attach the pads to the patient. When it begins to analyze the patient's cardiac rhythm, it signals 'low battery' and then shuts off. You have no other batteries available, and an electrical plug is not available. The patient subsequently dies despite adequate CPR and advanced airway and ventilation during transport. Which of the following could result?
Correct answer
B
Rationale
The correct answer is B: Negligence charges could be brought against the paramedic in charge of the unit.
Rationale:
1. Negligence is the failure to exercise the standard of care that a reasonably prudent person would have in a similar situation.
2. In this scenario, the paramedic in charge failed to ensure the equipment was adequately charged or had backup batteries, leading to the device shutting off during a critical moment.
3. This failure to provide proper equipment falls below the standard of care expected in the field of emergency medical services.
4. As a result, the patient's death could be attributed to the paramedic's negligence in ensuring equipment readiness.
Summary:
A: Manslaughter charges require a higher level of intent and causation, not applicable here.
C: Battery charges refer to physical harm, not applicable in this context.
D: Defamation charges involve false statements damaging a person's reputation, not relevant to the situation described.
Rationale:
1. Negligence is the failure to exercise the standard of care that a reasonably prudent person would have in a similar situation.
2. In this scenario, the paramedic in charge failed to ensure the equipment was adequately charged or had backup batteries, leading to the device shutting off during a critical moment.
3. This failure to provide proper equipment falls below the standard of care expected in the field of emergency medical services.
4. As a result, the patient's death could be attributed to the paramedic's negligence in ensuring equipment readiness.
Summary:
A: Manslaughter charges require a higher level of intent and causation, not applicable here.
C: Battery charges refer to physical harm, not applicable in this context.
D: Defamation charges involve false statements damaging a person's reputation, not relevant to the situation described.