Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 92%
Practice
Which test is the most specific test to diagnose an ACL tear?
Correct answer
A
Rationale
The correct answer is A: Pivot shift. This test is the most specific for diagnosing an ACL tear because it assesses the rotational instability of the knee joint, which is a key characteristic of an ACL injury. During the test, the examiner applies a valgus force and internal rotation to the knee while extending it, causing the tibia to subluxate anteriorly. If there is an ACL tear, the tibia will suddenly reduce back into place, producing a characteristic "pivot shift" movement.
Summary of other choices:
B: Lachman test - While also used to assess ACL integrity, it primarily evaluates anterior translation of the tibia and is not as specific for rotational instability.
C: Anterior drawer sign - This test is primarily used to assess anterior translation of the tibia and is not specific to diagnosing an ACL tear.
D: Ege's test - This test is not commonly used in clinical practice for diagnosing ACL tears.
Summary of other choices:
B: Lachman test - While also used to assess ACL integrity, it primarily evaluates anterior translation of the tibia and is not as specific for rotational instability.
C: Anterior drawer sign - This test is primarily used to assess anterior translation of the tibia and is not specific to diagnosing an ACL tear.
D: Ege's test - This test is not commonly used in clinical practice for diagnosing ACL tears.