Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 79%
Practice
Which question should the nurse ask to obtain the most valid information during a 24-hour diet recall?
Correct answer
A
Rationale
The most valid information during a 24-hour diet recall can be obtained by asking open-ended questions that encourage the patient to provide detailed information about their dietary intake. Choice A, "What did you put on your spaghetti?" is the most appropriate question as it allows the patient to freely list all the ingredients they added to their spaghetti without leading them towards a specific answer. This open-ended question promotes accurate and detailed recall of the patient's dietary choices.
Choice B, "Was the spaghetti with meat sauce?" is a closed-ended question that limits the patient's response to a simple yes or no answer. This type of question may overlook additional ingredients or details that the patient might have included in their meal.
Choice C, "Were there meatballs with the spaghetti?" is also a closed-ended question that restricts the patient's response to a specific detail. While it focuses on a specific ingredient, it may not capture other items the patient consumed with their spaghetti.
Choice D, "Did you sprinkle cheese on your spaghetti?" is another closed-ended question that only targets one specific ingredient. While cheese may be a significant aspect of the patient's dietary intake, this question does not encourage the patient to provide a comprehensive list of all the ingredients they consumed during the meal.
In conclusion, Choice A is the most appropriate question for obtaining valid information during a 24-hour diet recall as it allows for a detailed and unrestricted response from the patient. Open-ended questions are crucial in ensuring accurate and comprehensive dietary information is collected during a dietary recall session.
Choice B, "Was the spaghetti with meat sauce?" is a closed-ended question that limits the patient's response to a simple yes or no answer. This type of question may overlook additional ingredients or details that the patient might have included in their meal.
Choice C, "Were there meatballs with the spaghetti?" is also a closed-ended question that restricts the patient's response to a specific detail. While it focuses on a specific ingredient, it may not capture other items the patient consumed with their spaghetti.
Choice D, "Did you sprinkle cheese on your spaghetti?" is another closed-ended question that only targets one specific ingredient. While cheese may be a significant aspect of the patient's dietary intake, this question does not encourage the patient to provide a comprehensive list of all the ingredients they consumed during the meal.
In conclusion, Choice A is the most appropriate question for obtaining valid information during a 24-hour diet recall as it allows for a detailed and unrestricted response from the patient. Open-ended questions are crucial in ensuring accurate and comprehensive dietary information is collected during a dietary recall session.