Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 68%
Practice
Which of the following most accurately describes the participation of prisoners in clinical trials and research?
Correct answer
D
Rationale
Prisoners have the right to participate in clinical research trials. They are also entitled to monetary compensation for their participation. Participation cannot be used as a criterion for shortening their prison sentence. Essentially, prisoners have all the same rights in terms of their participation in clinical research as nonprisoners. This also includes the right to refuse participation. It is not unethical for them to participate. The ethical difficulties begin when the power of choice and informed consent are removed from the prisoner. Incarceration does not reduce the prisoner to the subhuman, animal-like status of unfair treatment or not having the right to refuse participation. Clinical trials that occur in a prison must undergo the same review process by an institutional review board (IRB) as those occurring outside the prison. You cannot force someone into research just because he is a prisoner. You cannot coerce them into participating by suggesting it will shorten the prison sentence.