Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 79%
Practice
Researches from the Cleveland Clinic (OH, USA) found that a microbiome present in breast tissue may be associated with breast cancer (Oncotarget 2017; 8:88122-88138). They hope to find a biomarker which help in fast and easy breast cancer diagnosis. Let us assume that they have already found such an biomarker and prepared a diagnostic test for detecting its presence. Using this test they examined 100 women with breast cancer and 100 healthy women who were diagnosed with other methods. They obtained the following results: Indicate the false interpretation of those results:
Correct answer
B
Rationale
The correct answer is B because the specificity of a diagnostic test measures its ability to correctly identify true negative cases. In this scenario, the test specificity is calculated as 89% (89 true negatives out of 100 healthy women). Therefore, the statement that the test specificity is 11% is false.
Option A is incorrect because test sensitivity refers to the ability of the test to correctly identify true positive cases, not false positives.
Option C is incorrect as it states that the percentage of false positive results is 11%, which contradicts the specificity calculation and the definition of false positives.
Option D is incorrect because it refers to the percentage of false negatives, which is not directly relevant to the calculation of specificity.
In an educational context, understanding the concepts of sensitivity and specificity in diagnostic testing is crucial for healthcare professionals to accurately interpret test results and make informed decisions regarding patient care. This question highlights the importance of correctly interpreting test performance metrics to avoid misdiagnosis and ensure appropriate patient management.
Option A is incorrect because test sensitivity refers to the ability of the test to correctly identify true positive cases, not false positives.
Option C is incorrect as it states that the percentage of false positive results is 11%, which contradicts the specificity calculation and the definition of false positives.
Option D is incorrect because it refers to the percentage of false negatives, which is not directly relevant to the calculation of specificity.
In an educational context, understanding the concepts of sensitivity and specificity in diagnostic testing is crucial for healthcare professionals to accurately interpret test results and make informed decisions regarding patient care. This question highlights the importance of correctly interpreting test performance metrics to avoid misdiagnosis and ensure appropriate patient management.