Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 90%
Practice
Let us assume that a new screening test was prepared to detect ovarian cancer. The chart below shows the frequency of its results. Which of the following is true if we take as a referential value the result of 0-30 ├é┬Ág/dL ?
Correct answer
C
Rationale
In this scenario, the correct answer is C) some healthy women will have a false-positive result. This is because when the reference value is set at 0-30 ┬Ág/dL, there is likely to be an overlap in results between healthy individuals and those with ovarian cancer. This overlap can lead to false-positive results in some healthy women who do not actually have the disease but test positive due to the test's sensitivity at this cutoff point.
Option A) test is in 100% specific and Option B) test is in 100% sensitive are incorrect because a test that is 100% specific would not yield any false positives, and a test that is 100% sensitive would not miss any true positive cases. However, in reality, most tests have a trade-off between sensitivity and specificity, leading to some degree of false positives and false negatives.
Option D) all women with cancer will have a positive result is incorrect because not all women with ovarian cancer will necessarily test positive at the 0-30 ┬Ág/dL cutoff. Some women with cancer may fall below this threshold, resulting in false-negative results.
From an educational standpoint, understanding the concepts of sensitivity, specificity, false positives, and false negatives in medical testing is crucial for healthcare professionals involved in screening and diagnostic processes. It highlights the importance of interpreting test results in conjunction with clinical findings and patient history to make informed decisions about further evaluation and treatment.
Option A) test is in 100% specific and Option B) test is in 100% sensitive are incorrect because a test that is 100% specific would not yield any false positives, and a test that is 100% sensitive would not miss any true positive cases. However, in reality, most tests have a trade-off between sensitivity and specificity, leading to some degree of false positives and false negatives.
Option D) all women with cancer will have a positive result is incorrect because not all women with ovarian cancer will necessarily test positive at the 0-30 ┬Ág/dL cutoff. Some women with cancer may fall below this threshold, resulting in false-negative results.
From an educational standpoint, understanding the concepts of sensitivity, specificity, false positives, and false negatives in medical testing is crucial for healthcare professionals involved in screening and diagnostic processes. It highlights the importance of interpreting test results in conjunction with clinical findings and patient history to make informed decisions about further evaluation and treatment.