Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 66%
Practice
Lenore White is an 80-year-old woman who smokes two packs of cigarettes per day. What two ethical principles are in conflict?
Correct answer
D
Rationale
In this scenario, the correct answer is D) Autonomy and nonmaleficence. Autonomy refers to the patient's right to make decisions about their own health, while nonmaleficence is the ethical principle of doing no harm to the patient. In the case of Lenore White, who is an 80-year-old woman smoking two packs of cigarettes per day, there is a conflict between her autonomy to smoke and the healthcare provider's duty to prevent harm, which aligns with the principle of nonmaleficence.
Option A) Beneficence and community is incorrect because beneficence refers to the obligation to act in the patient's best interest, which may conflict with autonomy but not in this scenario. Community is not directly relevant to the conflict presented.
Option B) Nonmaleficence and justice is incorrect because justice refers to fair and equal distribution of resources and treatment, which is not the primary conflict in this case.
Option C) Autonomy and justice is incorrect because justice does not directly conflict with autonomy in this context. The primary conflict is between autonomy and nonmaleficence.
This question highlights the ethical dilemma healthcare providers may face when balancing patient autonomy and the duty to prevent harm, especially in cases where a patient's choices may be detrimental to their health. It underscores the importance of understanding and navigating these ethical principles in clinical practice to provide optimal care while respecting patient autonomy.
Option A) Beneficence and community is incorrect because beneficence refers to the obligation to act in the patient's best interest, which may conflict with autonomy but not in this scenario. Community is not directly relevant to the conflict presented.
Option B) Nonmaleficence and justice is incorrect because justice refers to fair and equal distribution of resources and treatment, which is not the primary conflict in this case.
Option C) Autonomy and justice is incorrect because justice does not directly conflict with autonomy in this context. The primary conflict is between autonomy and nonmaleficence.
This question highlights the ethical dilemma healthcare providers may face when balancing patient autonomy and the duty to prevent harm, especially in cases where a patient's choices may be detrimental to their health. It underscores the importance of understanding and navigating these ethical principles in clinical practice to provide optimal care while respecting patient autonomy.