Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 77%
Practice
In a team meeting, a nurse says, 'I'm concerned whether we are behaving ethically by using restraint to prevent one patient from self-mutilation while the care plan for another patient who has also self-mutilated calls for one-on-one supervision.' Which ethical principle most clearly applies to this situation?
Correct answer
D
Rationale
The correct answer is D) Justice. In this scenario, justice is the ethical principle that most clearly applies. Justice in healthcare ethics refers to the fair distribution of resources and the equitable treatment of all individuals. The nurse's concern about using restraint for one patient while providing one-on-one supervision for another patient highlights the issue of fairness and equity in care delivery.
Option A) Beneficence, focuses on doing good and promoting the well-being of patients. While using restraint may be viewed as a way to prevent harm, the issue at hand is more about fairness and justice in resource allocation.
Option B) Autonomy, pertains to respecting patients' rights to make their own decisions about their care. Although autonomy is an important ethical principle, it is not the primary concern in this situation.
Option C) Fidelity, relates to being faithful to commitments and agreements made with patients. While fidelity is crucial in building trust with patients, it is not the central ethical principle at play in the nurse's dilemma.
Educationally, understanding the ethical principles in nursing is vital for making sound clinical decisions and providing ethical care. Nurses must navigate complex ethical dilemmas like the one presented in this question to ensure that their practice upholds the principles of justice, beneficence, autonomy, and fidelity. This scenario underscores the importance of considering fairness and equity in healthcare decision-making processes.
Option A) Beneficence, focuses on doing good and promoting the well-being of patients. While using restraint may be viewed as a way to prevent harm, the issue at hand is more about fairness and justice in resource allocation.
Option B) Autonomy, pertains to respecting patients' rights to make their own decisions about their care. Although autonomy is an important ethical principle, it is not the primary concern in this situation.
Option C) Fidelity, relates to being faithful to commitments and agreements made with patients. While fidelity is crucial in building trust with patients, it is not the central ethical principle at play in the nurse's dilemma.
Educationally, understanding the ethical principles in nursing is vital for making sound clinical decisions and providing ethical care. Nurses must navigate complex ethical dilemmas like the one presented in this question to ensure that their practice upholds the principles of justice, beneficence, autonomy, and fidelity. This scenario underscores the importance of considering fairness and equity in healthcare decision-making processes.