Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 78%
Practice
In a team meeting a nurse says, 'IÔÇÖm concerned about whether we are behaving ethically by using restraint to prevent one patient from self-mutilation, while the care plan for another self-mutilating patient requires one-on-one supervision' Which ethical principle most clearly applies to this situation?
Correct answer
D
Rationale
In this scenario, the correct ethical principle that most clearly applies is D) Justice. Justice in healthcare ethics pertains to fairness and equity in the distribution of resources, including the fair allocation of care and treatment decisions. In this case, the nurse is questioning the fairness of using restraints for one patient while providing one-on-one supervision for another patient with similar self-mutilating behavior. This raises concerns about consistency and fairness in the application of interventions, highlighting the principle of justice.
Option A) Beneficence relates to the duty to do good and promote the well-being of patients, which is not the primary concern in this situation. Option B) Autonomy refers to respecting patients' rights to make decisions about their own care, which is not the main issue being discussed. Option C) Fidelity relates to the duty of healthcare providers to be faithful to their commitments and obligations, which is also not the central ethical principle at play here.
Educationally, this question helps students understand how ethical principles apply in real-world nursing scenarios, emphasizing the importance of considering justice in decision-making processes to ensure fairness and equality in patient care. It also prompts critical thinking about ethical dilemmas that nurses may encounter in practice, fostering ethical reasoning skills essential for providing high-quality and ethical patient care.
Option A) Beneficence relates to the duty to do good and promote the well-being of patients, which is not the primary concern in this situation. Option B) Autonomy refers to respecting patients' rights to make decisions about their own care, which is not the main issue being discussed. Option C) Fidelity relates to the duty of healthcare providers to be faithful to their commitments and obligations, which is also not the central ethical principle at play here.
Educationally, this question helps students understand how ethical principles apply in real-world nursing scenarios, emphasizing the importance of considering justice in decision-making processes to ensure fairness and equality in patient care. It also prompts critical thinking about ethical dilemmas that nurses may encounter in practice, fostering ethical reasoning skills essential for providing high-quality and ethical patient care.