Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 63%
Practice
Gina, A client in prolong labor said she cannot go on anymore. The health care team decided that both the child and the mother cannot anymore endure the process. The baby is premature and has a little chance of surviving. Caesarian section is not possible because Gina already lost enough blood during labor and additional losses would tend to be fatal. The husband decided that Gina should survive and gave his consent to terminate the fetus. The principle that will be used by the health care team is:
Correct answer
C
Rationale
In this scenario, the correct principle being applied by the healthcare team is justice. Justice in healthcare ethics refers to the fair and equal distribution of resources and benefits among individuals. In this case, the decision to prioritize the mother's survival over the fetus is based on the principle of justice as it aims to ensure fairness and equity in the allocation of limited resources (blood loss in this case).
Option A, beneficence, focuses on doing good for the patient, which may include actions to benefit both the mother and the fetus. However, in this specific scenario, the critical factor is the limited resources and the need to prioritize one life over the other.
Option B, non-malfeasance, pertains to the duty to do no harm. While it is essential in healthcare ethics, in this case, harm has already occurred due to the mother's critical condition and the need to make a decision based on available resources.
Option D, double effect, involves situations where an action has both a positive and negative effect. However, in this case, the primary consideration is the principle of justice in resource allocation rather than the double effect of an action.
Educationally, understanding and applying ethical principles like justice in healthcare decision-making is crucial for healthcare professionals to navigate complex situations ethically and professionally while considering the well-being of all involved parties.
Option A, beneficence, focuses on doing good for the patient, which may include actions to benefit both the mother and the fetus. However, in this specific scenario, the critical factor is the limited resources and the need to prioritize one life over the other.
Option B, non-malfeasance, pertains to the duty to do no harm. While it is essential in healthcare ethics, in this case, harm has already occurred due to the mother's critical condition and the need to make a decision based on available resources.
Option D, double effect, involves situations where an action has both a positive and negative effect. However, in this case, the primary consideration is the principle of justice in resource allocation rather than the double effect of an action.
Educationally, understanding and applying ethical principles like justice in healthcare decision-making is crucial for healthcare professionals to navigate complex situations ethically and professionally while considering the well-being of all involved parties.