Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 69%
Practice
Carolina is surprised when her patient does not show for a regularly scheduled appointment. When contacted, the patient states,
Correct answer
A
Rationale
Carolina's best response is **A: *"That sounds exciting, would you be willing to visit and show me the app?"*** because it demonstrates openness, curiosity, and a patient-centered approach. By validating the patientÔÇÖs interest in the app, Carolina fosters trust and keeps communication lines open. This response allows her to assess the appÔÇÖs credibility, discuss its integration with their ongoing therapy, and ensure the patient isnÔÇÖt abandoning evidence-based care prematurely. It also avoids defensiveness, which could alienate the patient. A collaborative approach encourages the patient to remain engaged while allowing Carolina to provide professional guidance on whether the app complements or conflicts with their treatment plan.
**B: *"At this time, there is no real evidence that the app can replace our therapy."*** is problematic because it dismisses the patientÔÇÖs autonomy and enthusiasm without exploration. While it may be true that many apps lack rigorous evidence, outright rejection can make the patient defensive. A better approach would involve discussing research together, evaluating the app's merits, and addressing gaps in its effectiveness rather than issuing a blanket dismissal. This response risks shutting down dialogue and may push the patient further away from professional support.
**C: *"I am not sure that is a good idea right now, we are so close to progress."*** assumes that the therapist's perspective on progress outweighs the patientÔÇÖs agency. While the concern is validÔÇöabruptly stopping therapy can disrupt gainsÔÇöthis phrasing centers CarolinaÔÇÖs agenda rather than the patientÔÇÖs needs. It could come across as manipulative ("weÔÇÖre *so close*") rather than collaborative. A more effective approach would be acknowledging the patientÔÇÖs autonomy while discussing potential risks of discontinuing sessions.
**D: *"Why would you think that is a better option than meeting with me?"*** is the least constructive, as it frames the question confrontationally. This puts the patient in a position to justify their choice defensively, which could damage rapport. It implies that CarolinaÔÇÖs ego is more important than understanding the patientÔÇÖs perspective. Even if the app is inadequate, this response fails to guide the patient toward an informed decision, instead breeding resentment or withdrawal.
In summary, **A** succeeds because it balances professional guidance with respect for the patientÔÇÖs choices, fostering a partnership rather than authority-based compliance. The incorrect options either dismiss, manipulate, or challenge the patient in ways that undermine therapeutic trust. Effective responses in such scenarios prioritize curiosity, collaboration, and patient empowerment while ensuring clinical oversight.
**B: *"At this time, there is no real evidence that the app can replace our therapy."*** is problematic because it dismisses the patientÔÇÖs autonomy and enthusiasm without exploration. While it may be true that many apps lack rigorous evidence, outright rejection can make the patient defensive. A better approach would involve discussing research together, evaluating the app's merits, and addressing gaps in its effectiveness rather than issuing a blanket dismissal. This response risks shutting down dialogue and may push the patient further away from professional support.
**C: *"I am not sure that is a good idea right now, we are so close to progress."*** assumes that the therapist's perspective on progress outweighs the patientÔÇÖs agency. While the concern is validÔÇöabruptly stopping therapy can disrupt gainsÔÇöthis phrasing centers CarolinaÔÇÖs agenda rather than the patientÔÇÖs needs. It could come across as manipulative ("weÔÇÖre *so close*") rather than collaborative. A more effective approach would be acknowledging the patientÔÇÖs autonomy while discussing potential risks of discontinuing sessions.
**D: *"Why would you think that is a better option than meeting with me?"*** is the least constructive, as it frames the question confrontationally. This puts the patient in a position to justify their choice defensively, which could damage rapport. It implies that CarolinaÔÇÖs ego is more important than understanding the patientÔÇÖs perspective. Even if the app is inadequate, this response fails to guide the patient toward an informed decision, instead breeding resentment or withdrawal.
In summary, **A** succeeds because it balances professional guidance with respect for the patientÔÇÖs choices, fostering a partnership rather than authority-based compliance. The incorrect options either dismiss, manipulate, or challenge the patient in ways that undermine therapeutic trust. Effective responses in such scenarios prioritize curiosity, collaboration, and patient empowerment while ensuring clinical oversight.