Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 63%
Practice
Arthur has a family history of colon cancer and is scheduled to have a sigmoidoscopy. He is crying as he tells you, "I know that I have colon cancer, too." Which response is most therapeutic?
Correct answer
B
Rationale
The most therapeutic response in this scenario is option B, "You seem upset." This response demonstrates active listening and empathy towards Arthur's emotional state without making assumptions or providing false reassurance. By acknowledging his emotions, the nurse opens up a safe space for Arthur to express his concerns and fears, which can help build trust and facilitate effective communication.
Option A, "I know just how you feel," is not the best response because it invalidates Arthur's unique experience by assuming the nurse knows exactly how he feels. This can come across as dismissive and may hinder open dialogue.
Option C, "Oh, don't worry about it, everything will be just fine," is not appropriate as it provides false reassurance and minimizes Arthur's emotional distress. It fails to address his concerns and can lead to a breakdown in the therapeutic nurse-patient relationship.
Option D, "Why do you think you have cancer?" is not the most therapeutic response as it may come off as confrontational and could make Arthur feel defensive. This question puts the onus on Arthur to justify his feelings rather than focusing on addressing his emotional needs during this vulnerable moment.
In an educational context, it is essential for nursing students to understand the importance of therapeutic communication in building rapport with patients. Active listening, empathy, and validation of emotions are crucial skills that nurses must develop to provide holistic and patient-centered care. By choosing the most appropriate responses in challenging situations like this, nurses can support patients effectively through their emotional and physical health journeys.
Option A, "I know just how you feel," is not the best response because it invalidates Arthur's unique experience by assuming the nurse knows exactly how he feels. This can come across as dismissive and may hinder open dialogue.
Option C, "Oh, don't worry about it, everything will be just fine," is not appropriate as it provides false reassurance and minimizes Arthur's emotional distress. It fails to address his concerns and can lead to a breakdown in the therapeutic nurse-patient relationship.
Option D, "Why do you think you have cancer?" is not the most therapeutic response as it may come off as confrontational and could make Arthur feel defensive. This question puts the onus on Arthur to justify his feelings rather than focusing on addressing his emotional needs during this vulnerable moment.
In an educational context, it is essential for nursing students to understand the importance of therapeutic communication in building rapport with patients. Active listening, empathy, and validation of emotions are crucial skills that nurses must develop to provide holistic and patient-centered care. By choosing the most appropriate responses in challenging situations like this, nurses can support patients effectively through their emotional and physical health journeys.