Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 93%
Practice
After a long, exhausting hike, Stephanie went home and fell asleep on the couch, which she had done many times before. Which comma should be removed in the sentence above?
Correct answer
C
Rationale
The correct answer is C) The comma after the word 'home' should be removed.
In the sentence, "After a long, exhausting hike, Stephanie went home and fell asleep on the couch, which she had done many times before," the phrase "which she had done many times before" is a non-essential clause providing additional information about falling asleep on the couch. When we have a non-essential clause in the middle of a sentence, it should be set off by commas. However, if we remove the non-essential clause, the sentence reads, "After a long, exhausting hike, Stephanie went home and fell asleep on the couch." In this case, the comma after 'home' is unnecessary because it separates the verb 'went' from its object 'home,' causing a disruption in the sentence flow.
The other commas in the sentence serve specific purposes:
- The comma after 'long' is correct as it sets off an introductory word or phrase.
- The comma after 'hike' correctly sets off an introductory participial phrase.
- The comma after 'couch' is necessary to separate the main clause from the non-essential relative clause that follows.
Understanding when to use commas is essential in writing to ensure clarity and coherence. This question highlights the importance of punctuation rules in constructing well-structured sentences. Students need to grasp these rules to effectively convey their ideas and improve the readability of their writing.
In the sentence, "After a long, exhausting hike, Stephanie went home and fell asleep on the couch, which she had done many times before," the phrase "which she had done many times before" is a non-essential clause providing additional information about falling asleep on the couch. When we have a non-essential clause in the middle of a sentence, it should be set off by commas. However, if we remove the non-essential clause, the sentence reads, "After a long, exhausting hike, Stephanie went home and fell asleep on the couch." In this case, the comma after 'home' is unnecessary because it separates the verb 'went' from its object 'home,' causing a disruption in the sentence flow.
The other commas in the sentence serve specific purposes:
- The comma after 'long' is correct as it sets off an introductory word or phrase.
- The comma after 'hike' correctly sets off an introductory participial phrase.
- The comma after 'couch' is necessary to separate the main clause from the non-essential relative clause that follows.
Understanding when to use commas is essential in writing to ensure clarity and coherence. This question highlights the importance of punctuation rules in constructing well-structured sentences. Students need to grasp these rules to effectively convey their ideas and improve the readability of their writing.