Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 89%
Practice
A team of community health nurses (CHNs) disagree about the appropriate treatment for Mrs. Mehta, who is likely an excellent candidate for hospice care. The first CHN says that deciding on care, rather than cure, is up to Mrs. Mehta, and no one else can decide for her. The second CHN says that it is the responsibility of the health care team to do what is best for Mrs. Mehta, and if the physician thinks there is still a possibility of cure, then the CHNs should do everything they can to implement the treatment plan. The third CHN says it is not fair for the family to expend all their resources on Mrs. Mehta, who is probably going to die in spite of the care provided by the health care team. What conclusions can be drawn from this dispute?
Correct answer
A
Rationale
The correct answer is A: Ethical principles can conflict with each other.
- The first CHN emphasizes patient autonomy, allowing Mrs. Mehta to decide on her care.
- The second CHN prioritizes beneficence, aiming to provide the best care possible for Mrs. Mehta.
- The third CHN focuses on the principle of utility, seeking to maximize benefits for all involved.
- These conflicting perspectives highlight the complexity of ethical decision-making in healthcare where different principles may clash, requiring careful consideration and balancing of multiple values and priorities.
- The first CHN emphasizes patient autonomy, allowing Mrs. Mehta to decide on her care.
- The second CHN prioritizes beneficence, aiming to provide the best care possible for Mrs. Mehta.
- The third CHN focuses on the principle of utility, seeking to maximize benefits for all involved.
- These conflicting perspectives highlight the complexity of ethical decision-making in healthcare where different principles may clash, requiring careful consideration and balancing of multiple values and priorities.