Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 86%
Practice
A patient nearing the end of life requests that he be given no food or fluids. The physician orders the insertion of a nasogastric tube to feed the patient. What situation does this create for the nurse providing care?
Correct answer
C
Rationale
The correct answer is C because it highlights the ethical dilemma that arises from conflicting principles of patient autonomy and beneficence. By respecting the patient's wish to refuse food and fluids, the nurse would be supporting autonomy, but by following the physician's order to insert a feeding tube, the nurse would be prioritizing beneficence. This creates a moral distress for the nurse, as they are torn between two valid but conflicting courses of action.
A: Following physician's orders is important, but in this case, it conflicts with the patient's autonomy.
B: This choice is too extreme and does not address the ethical dilemma at hand.
D: While inserting a feeding tube may affect the nurse-patient relationship, the primary issue is the ethical conflict between respecting the patient's wishes and following medical orders.
A: Following physician's orders is important, but in this case, it conflicts with the patient's autonomy.
B: This choice is too extreme and does not address the ethical dilemma at hand.
D: While inserting a feeding tube may affect the nurse-patient relationship, the primary issue is the ethical conflict between respecting the patient's wishes and following medical orders.