Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 68%
Practice
A nurse is working with an active labor patient who is in preterm labor and has been designated as high risk. The patient is very apprehensive and asks the nurse, 'Is everything going to be all right?' The nurse replies, 'Yes, everything will be okay.' Following delivery via an emergency cesarean birth, the newborn undergoes resuscitation and does not survive. The patient is distraught over the outcome and blames the nurse for telling her that everything would be okay. Which ethical principle did the nurse violate?
Correct answer
B
Rationale
The correct answer is B) Fidelity. Fidelity refers to the ethical principle of being faithful and true to one's commitments and promises. In this scenario, the nurse violated fidelity by assuring the patient that everything would be okay without having certainty or control over the outcome. This breach of trust led to a sense of betrayal for the patient when the outcome was tragic.
Option A) Autonomy pertains to respecting the patient's right to make their own decisions. In this case, the nurse did not violate the patient's autonomy but failed in maintaining fidelity.
Option C) Beneficence involves acting in the patient's best interest. While the nurse's intention may have been to provide comfort, the lack of truthful information compromised beneficence.
Option D) Accountability refers to the responsibility of healthcare professionals for their actions. While accountability is important, the primary ethical principle violated in this scenario is fidelity.
In an educational context, this scenario highlights the significance of honesty and transparency in patient communication, especially in high-stress situations. Nurses must balance providing reassurance with being truthful and realistic to maintain trust and uphold ethical principles like fidelity in their practice.
Option A) Autonomy pertains to respecting the patient's right to make their own decisions. In this case, the nurse did not violate the patient's autonomy but failed in maintaining fidelity.
Option C) Beneficence involves acting in the patient's best interest. While the nurse's intention may have been to provide comfort, the lack of truthful information compromised beneficence.
Option D) Accountability refers to the responsibility of healthcare professionals for their actions. While accountability is important, the primary ethical principle violated in this scenario is fidelity.
In an educational context, this scenario highlights the significance of honesty and transparency in patient communication, especially in high-stress situations. Nurses must balance providing reassurance with being truthful and realistic to maintain trust and uphold ethical principles like fidelity in their practice.