Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 62%
Practice
A nurse is providing care for a surgeon on a medical-surgical unit. A nurse from another unit asks the nurse about the surgeon's medical diagnosis. The nurse responds that he is unable to provide the information requested. The nurse is displaying which of the following ethical principles?
Correct answer
D
Rationale
The correct answer is D: Nonmaleficence. The nurse is upholding the principle of nonmaleficence by not disclosing the surgeon's medical diagnosis, as it could potentially harm the surgeon's privacy and confidentiality. Nonmaleficence means to do no harm and to prevent harm. The other choices are incorrect because:
A: Utility - This principle focuses on maximizing benefits for the greatest number of people. Not disclosing the surgeon's diagnosis does not directly relate to maximizing benefits.
B: Paternalism - This principle involves making decisions for someone else's best interest without their consent. The nurse's actions are not paternalistic as they are respecting the surgeon's right to privacy.
C: Justice - This principle focuses on fairness and equal treatment. Not disclosing the diagnosis does not directly relate to justice in this scenario.
A: Utility - This principle focuses on maximizing benefits for the greatest number of people. Not disclosing the surgeon's diagnosis does not directly relate to maximizing benefits.
B: Paternalism - This principle involves making decisions for someone else's best interest without their consent. The nurse's actions are not paternalistic as they are respecting the surgeon's right to privacy.
C: Justice - This principle focuses on fairness and equal treatment. Not disclosing the diagnosis does not directly relate to justice in this scenario.