Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 76%
Practice
A nurse is participating in an ethics committee meeting about a client who has a history of alcohol use disorder and needs a liver transplant. Which of the following actions should the committee take first?
Correct answer
A
Rationale
Ethical decision-making starts with understanding the issue fully, per evidence-based frameworks. Collecting information client history, medical status, transplant criteria grounds the committee's deliberation in facts, clarifying complexities (e.g., alcohol relapse risk vs. urgent need) before judging eligibility. Deciding first skips data, risking bias like stigmatizing alcohol use disorder while consulting the surgeon or reviewing policy alone narrows focus prematurely. Gathering data ensures a holistic view, balancing beneficence (transplant benefit) and justice (fair allocation), guiding a defensible, equitable outcome. This step establishes the ethical problem's scope, critical for a transplant's life-or-death stakes, fostering informed, impartial discussion.