Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 95%
Practice
A nurse believes that it is his responsibility to ensure the safety of the public by administering flu shots to everyone in the community. Which ethical theory is being used by the nurse?
Correct answer
C
Rationale
In this scenario, the nurse is applying consequentialism theory. Consequentialism is an ethical theory that focuses on the outcomes or consequences of actions. In this case, the nurse believes that by administering flu shots to everyone in the community, they are maximizing the overall benefit (public safety) and minimizing harm (spread of flu), which aligns with the principle of maximizing good outcomes.
Option A, descriptive value theory, pertains to describing values that are held without making judgments about their validity or moral worth. This does not apply to the nurse's actions, as they are actively making a decision based on a perceived ethical responsibility.
Option B, normative theory, refers to theories that prescribe how things should or ought to be. While the nurse's actions do involve a sense of obligation, the specific ethical framework being applied is consequentialism, not just a normative guideline.
Option D, duty-based theory, typically refers to ethical frameworks like Kantian ethics, which focus on the inherent rightness or wrongness of actions based on adherence to duties or rules. While the nurse may have a sense of duty, the primary driving force behind the decision to administer flu shots to all is the expected positive consequences on public safety.
In an educational context, understanding different ethical theories is crucial for healthcare professionals like nurses to navigate complex moral dilemmas and make ethically sound decisions in their practice. By recognizing and applying appropriate ethical frameworks, nurses can ensure that their actions align with the values of beneficence, non-maleficence, justice, and autonomy, promoting the best possible outcomes for their patients and the community.
Option A, descriptive value theory, pertains to describing values that are held without making judgments about their validity or moral worth. This does not apply to the nurse's actions, as they are actively making a decision based on a perceived ethical responsibility.
Option B, normative theory, refers to theories that prescribe how things should or ought to be. While the nurse's actions do involve a sense of obligation, the specific ethical framework being applied is consequentialism, not just a normative guideline.
Option D, duty-based theory, typically refers to ethical frameworks like Kantian ethics, which focus on the inherent rightness or wrongness of actions based on adherence to duties or rules. While the nurse may have a sense of duty, the primary driving force behind the decision to administer flu shots to all is the expected positive consequences on public safety.
In an educational context, understanding different ethical theories is crucial for healthcare professionals like nurses to navigate complex moral dilemmas and make ethically sound decisions in their practice. By recognizing and applying appropriate ethical frameworks, nurses can ensure that their actions align with the values of beneficence, non-maleficence, justice, and autonomy, promoting the best possible outcomes for their patients and the community.