Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 79%
Practice
A liver for which two people are tissue-typed has become available after the death of a donor in a car accident. Client A is a 45-year-old substance abuser whose liver is damaged as a result of his use of alcohol. Client B is a 16-year-old adolescent in need of a liver transplant because of a birth abnormality. Which of the following would be useful for a nurse in giving input as to which of the two should receive the liver?
Correct answer
C
Rationale
In this scenario, the correct answer is C) Use a guided set of moral principles in decision-making before advocating for either. This response reflects the ethical principle of justice, which emphasizes fairness and impartiality in decision-making. When allocating a scarce resource like a liver for transplantation, it is crucial to consider factors beyond age or personal history, such as the urgency of need, potential for success of the transplant, quality of life post-transplant, and overall benefit to society.
Option A is incorrect because age alone should not be the sole determinant in organ allocation, as it overlooks other relevant factors. Option B is not appropriate as it suggests favoring one client based on personal biases or subjective moral theories. Option D is flawed as it assumes that Client A's remaining years of life are the sole criteria for organ allocation, neglecting other important considerations such as quality of life and potential benefit to society.
In the field of pharmacology and healthcare, ethical decision-making is paramount. Nurses and healthcare professionals must adhere to ethical principles, guidelines, and moral frameworks to ensure fair and just allocation of resources and treatment decisions. By using a guided set of moral principles, healthcare providers can navigate complex ethical dilemmas like organ allocation with integrity and fairness, ultimately promoting better health outcomes for all patients involved.
Option A is incorrect because age alone should not be the sole determinant in organ allocation, as it overlooks other relevant factors. Option B is not appropriate as it suggests favoring one client based on personal biases or subjective moral theories. Option D is flawed as it assumes that Client A's remaining years of life are the sole criteria for organ allocation, neglecting other important considerations such as quality of life and potential benefit to society.
In the field of pharmacology and healthcare, ethical decision-making is paramount. Nurses and healthcare professionals must adhere to ethical principles, guidelines, and moral frameworks to ensure fair and just allocation of resources and treatment decisions. By using a guided set of moral principles, healthcare providers can navigate complex ethical dilemmas like organ allocation with integrity and fairness, ultimately promoting better health outcomes for all patients involved.