Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 62%
Practice
A hundred college freshmen were monitored for colds during the winter. 55 are smokers. 75% of the smokers had 2 or more colds. $20 \%$ of the non-smokers had 2 or more colds. What type of study was this?
Correct answer
B
Rationale
In this scenario, the correct type of study is a cohort study (Option B). A cohort study involves following a group of individuals over a period of time to observe how their exposure to certain factors (in this case, smoking status) relates to the development of specific outcomes (having 2 or more colds).
The cohort study is the correct choice because the study started with a group of college freshmen (the cohort) and then monitored them over time to compare the incidence of colds in smokers and non-smokers. This allows for the determination of a causal relationship between smoking and colds.
The other options are incorrect because:
- A) Case-control studies start with individuals who have the outcome of interest (colds) and match them with individuals without the outcome to compare exposures. This study did not follow that design.
- C) Cross-sectional studies collect data at a single point in time, which would not allow for the observation of the development of colds over time in relation to smoking.
- D) Period prevalence refers to the proportion of a population that has a certain condition at a specific point in time, which does not align with the study design described.
Understanding different types of study designs is crucial for researchers and healthcare professionals to accurately interpret and apply research findings in practice. Cohort studies are particularly valuable for establishing causal relationships between exposures and outcomes over time.
The cohort study is the correct choice because the study started with a group of college freshmen (the cohort) and then monitored them over time to compare the incidence of colds in smokers and non-smokers. This allows for the determination of a causal relationship between smoking and colds.
The other options are incorrect because:
- A) Case-control studies start with individuals who have the outcome of interest (colds) and match them with individuals without the outcome to compare exposures. This study did not follow that design.
- C) Cross-sectional studies collect data at a single point in time, which would not allow for the observation of the development of colds over time in relation to smoking.
- D) Period prevalence refers to the proportion of a population that has a certain condition at a specific point in time, which does not align with the study design described.
Understanding different types of study designs is crucial for researchers and healthcare professionals to accurately interpret and apply research findings in practice. Cohort studies are particularly valuable for establishing causal relationships between exposures and outcomes over time.