Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 64%
Practice
A client being served in a busy inpatient psychiatric unit becomes very noisy and combative. The other clients are complaining about the noise and are afraid that they will be hurt by the client. The nurse determines that the best course of action for all involved is to seclude the client until the client is able to regain control of his behavior. On which ethical principle did the nurse base this decision?
Correct answer
A
Rationale
Utilitarianism is a theory that bases decisions on the 'greatest good for the greatest number.' While the client may experience a temporary loss of freedom, all of the clients on the nursing unit and their visitors will benefit by not being at risk for harm from this client. Deontology is a theory that says decisions should be based on whether or not an action is morally right with no regard for the result or consequences. It may not be considered morally right to deny this client his freedom for any amount of time, irrespective of the consequences (harm to others). Nonmaleficence is the requirement to do no harm to others either intentionally or unintentionally. In this circumstance, it could be argued that secluding the client could be maleficence, but it also could be argued that the other clients' rights to not be harmed would be violated by not secluding this client until he is able to regain control of his behavior. Justice refers to fairness, that is, treating all people fairly and equally without regard for social or economic status, race, sex, marital status, religion, ethnicity, or cultural beliefs. It could be argued that the client was not treated fairly when he was secluded, but it also could be argued that the others were not treated fairly if the client was allowed to continue to freely engage in the disrupting behavior.