Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 82%
Practice
A 56-year-old man is thrown violently against the steering wheel of his truck during a motor vehicle crash. On arrival in the ED he is diaphoretic and complaining of chest pain. His BP is 60/40mmHg and his respiratory rate is 40 breaths per minute. Which of the following best differentiates cardiac tamponade from tension pneumothorax as the cause of his hypotension?
Correct answer
C
Rationale
The correct answer is C: Breath sounds. In cardiac tamponade, there may be muffled heart sounds and distant or absent breath sounds due to the accumulation of fluid around the heart, compressing the lungs. This differentiates it from tension pneumothorax, where there is hyperresonance to percussion and decreased or absent breath sounds on the affected side.
A: Tachycardia is a common feature of both cardiac tamponade and tension pneumothorax, so it does not differentiate between the two conditions.
B: Pulse volume may be decreased in both cardiac tamponade and tension pneumothorax, so it is not the best differentiator.
D: Pulse pressure may be narrowed in both conditions, so it is not the most specific differentiating factor.
A: Tachycardia is a common feature of both cardiac tamponade and tension pneumothorax, so it does not differentiate between the two conditions.
B: Pulse volume may be decreased in both cardiac tamponade and tension pneumothorax, so it is not the best differentiator.
D: Pulse pressure may be narrowed in both conditions, so it is not the most specific differentiating factor.