Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 78%
Practice
A 52-year-old man with cerebral palsy is being evaluated for screening colonoscopy. He has a mental age of 8 and a second grade reading level in terms of comprehension. He lives alone and survives on a combination of public assistance and a low paying part-time job sweeping floors. You have thoroughly explained the procedure to him in terms of risks and benefits. He repeatedly refuses the procedure entirely on the basis of 'I just don't want it.' What should you do?
Correct answer
C
Rationale
Just because a patient may be incompetent in certain areas of his life does not mean that he is not able to consent for medical procedures. The patient described has a severe and permanent cognitive impairment; however, he is still able to refuse the procedure. A patient can be considered incompetent for financial issues but still have the ability to make medical decisions. It would not be advisable to recommend routine medical procedures against the will of the patient. This would mean literally forcing him into the endoscopy through restraints or sedation. Incompetence in one area does not mean total incompetence. The court recognizes a much lower standard of cognitive ability to reliably consent or refuse procedures compared with financial decisions. It is easier to be declared incompetent for financial decisions than it is for medical decisions.