Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 85%
Practice
A 48 year old man has moderate epigastric pain for 2 days and is seen at his GP surgery. He had a duodenal ulcer 6 months ago and was treated with Helicobacter pylori eradication therapy. Which is the most appropriate test to confirm Helicobacter pylori eradication?
Correct answer
A
Rationale
In this scenario, the most appropriate test to confirm Helicobacter pylori eradication in a 48-year-old man with a history of duodenal ulcer and prior treatment is option A) C13 urea breath test. This test is considered the gold standard for confirming eradication as it directly detects the presence of active H. pylori infection. The C13 urea breath test is non-invasive, accurate, and has high sensitivity and specificity.
Option B) Faecal Helicobacter antigen is not the best choice in this case as it is more useful for diagnosing current H. pylori infection rather than confirming eradication after treatment. Option C) Gastric aspirate urease test is invasive and less commonly used in clinical practice due to its discomfort and inconvenience. Option D) Helicobacter pylori serology can detect antibodies to H. pylori, but it may remain positive even after successful eradication, leading to false-positive results.
From an educational perspective, it is important for nurses and healthcare providers to understand the rationale behind selecting the appropriate diagnostic test based on the clinical scenario, patient history, and treatment context. By choosing the C13 urea breath test in this case, healthcare professionals can accurately confirm the eradication of H. pylori infection and guide further management decisions effectively.
Option B) Faecal Helicobacter antigen is not the best choice in this case as it is more useful for diagnosing current H. pylori infection rather than confirming eradication after treatment. Option C) Gastric aspirate urease test is invasive and less commonly used in clinical practice due to its discomfort and inconvenience. Option D) Helicobacter pylori serology can detect antibodies to H. pylori, but it may remain positive even after successful eradication, leading to false-positive results.
From an educational perspective, it is important for nurses and healthcare providers to understand the rationale behind selecting the appropriate diagnostic test based on the clinical scenario, patient history, and treatment context. By choosing the C13 urea breath test in this case, healthcare professionals can accurately confirm the eradication of H. pylori infection and guide further management decisions effectively.