Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 69%
Practice
A 3-month-old baby has been diagnosed with cystic fibrosis (CF). The mother says, 'How could this happen? I had an amniocentesis during my pregnancy and everything was supposed to be normal!' What must the nurse understand about this situation?
Correct answer
B
Rationale
In this scenario, the correct answer is B) The baby may have an uncommon genetic variant of the disease. This is because cystic fibrosis (CF) is a genetic disorder that can be caused by various mutations in the CFTR gene. While some genetic tests, including amniocentesis, can detect certain common mutations associated with CF, they may not identify all possible genetic variants that can lead to the disease. Therefore, it is possible for a baby to have an uncommon genetic variant of CF that was not detected during the mother's prenatal testing.
Option A) Cystic fibrosis cannot be diagnosed by amniocentesis is incorrect because while amniocentesis may detect some common mutations associated with CF, it is not exhaustive and may miss uncommon genetic variants.
Option C) It is possible that the laboratory technician made an error is incorrect as the issue lies more with the limitations of the genetic testing methods rather than a technician error.
Option D) Instead of obtaining fetal cells the doctor probably harvested maternal cells is incorrect as amniocentesis is specifically designed to obtain fetal cells for genetic testing, and harvesting maternal cells would not provide accurate information about the baby's genetic status.
Educationally, this question highlights the complexity of genetic testing for conditions like cystic fibrosis and emphasizes the importance of understanding the limitations of prenatal diagnostic tests in detecting all possible genetic variants that can lead to a disease. It underscores the need for comprehensive genetic counseling and testing to provide accurate information to parents about their baby's health.
Option A) Cystic fibrosis cannot be diagnosed by amniocentesis is incorrect because while amniocentesis may detect some common mutations associated with CF, it is not exhaustive and may miss uncommon genetic variants.
Option C) It is possible that the laboratory technician made an error is incorrect as the issue lies more with the limitations of the genetic testing methods rather than a technician error.
Option D) Instead of obtaining fetal cells the doctor probably harvested maternal cells is incorrect as amniocentesis is specifically designed to obtain fetal cells for genetic testing, and harvesting maternal cells would not provide accurate information about the baby's genetic status.
Educationally, this question highlights the complexity of genetic testing for conditions like cystic fibrosis and emphasizes the importance of understanding the limitations of prenatal diagnostic tests in detecting all possible genetic variants that can lead to a disease. It underscores the need for comprehensive genetic counseling and testing to provide accurate information to parents about their baby's health.