Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 67%
Testbank
In a team meeting, a nurse says, 'I'm concerned whether we are behaving ethically by using restraint to prevent one patient from self-mutilation while the care plan for another patient who has also self-mutilated calls for one-on-one supervision.' Which ethical principle most clearly applies to this situation?
Correct answer
D
Rationale
Justice. This principle emphasizes fairness and equality in treatment, ensuring that all patients receive appropriate care based on their individual needs and circumstances.
D: Justice is applicable here as the nurse's concern reflects the need to assess whether both patients are receiving equitable care. The disparity in interventions for similar behaviors raises ethical questions about fairness in treatment approaches.
A: Beneficence focuses on promoting the well-being of patients, but the nurse's concern is about the ethical implications of differing treatment approaches rather than the effectiveness of care provided.
B: Autonomy involves respecting a patient's right to make their own decisions, yet this situation centers on the ethical considerations of restraint and supervision, rather than individual patient choices.
C: Fidelity pertains to maintaining trust and keeping promises in the nurse-patient relationship, but the core issue here is the equitable treatment of patients, not the nurse's commitment to patients.
D: Justice is applicable here as the nurse's concern reflects the need to assess whether both patients are receiving equitable care. The disparity in interventions for similar behaviors raises ethical questions about fairness in treatment approaches.
A: Beneficence focuses on promoting the well-being of patients, but the nurse's concern is about the ethical implications of differing treatment approaches rather than the effectiveness of care provided.
B: Autonomy involves respecting a patient's right to make their own decisions, yet this situation centers on the ethical considerations of restraint and supervision, rather than individual patient choices.
C: Fidelity pertains to maintaining trust and keeping promises in the nurse-patient relationship, but the core issue here is the equitable treatment of patients, not the nurse's commitment to patients.