Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 80%
Testbank
A critical care nurse asks a psychiatric nurse about the difference between a diagnosis in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5) and a nursing diagnosis. What is the psychiatric nurse's best response?
Correct answer
D
Rationale
D: The DSM-5 diagnosis influences the medical treatment; the nursing diagnosis offers a framework to identify interventions for problems a patient has or may experience.
This option accurately reflects the primary distinction between the two types of diagnoses. The DSM-5 focuses on categorizing mental disorders to guide medical treatment, while nursing diagnoses prioritize the identification of patient-specific needs and interventions, fostering a holistic approach to care.
A: No functional difference exists between the two diagnoses. Both serve to identify a human deviance. This option fails because it overlooks the distinct purposes of each diagnosis; the DSM-5 is clinically oriented, while nursing diagnoses focus on patient care and interventions.
B: The DSM-5 diagnosis disregards culture, whereas the nursing diagnosis includes cultural variables. This option is misleading as both types of diagnoses can consider cultural factors, but their primary distinctions lie in their focus and application rather than cultural considerations.
C: The DSM-5 diagnosis profiles present distress or disability, whereas a nursing diagnosis considers past and present responses to actual mental health problems. While partially accurate, this option does not fully capture the primary role of nursing diagnoses in guiding interventions, which is central to the question.
This option accurately reflects the primary distinction between the two types of diagnoses. The DSM-5 focuses on categorizing mental disorders to guide medical treatment, while nursing diagnoses prioritize the identification of patient-specific needs and interventions, fostering a holistic approach to care.
A: No functional difference exists between the two diagnoses. Both serve to identify a human deviance. This option fails because it overlooks the distinct purposes of each diagnosis; the DSM-5 is clinically oriented, while nursing diagnoses focus on patient care and interventions.
B: The DSM-5 diagnosis disregards culture, whereas the nursing diagnosis includes cultural variables. This option is misleading as both types of diagnoses can consider cultural factors, but their primary distinctions lie in their focus and application rather than cultural considerations.
C: The DSM-5 diagnosis profiles present distress or disability, whereas a nursing diagnosis considers past and present responses to actual mental health problems. While partially accurate, this option does not fully capture the primary role of nursing diagnoses in guiding interventions, which is central to the question.