Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 93%
Testbank
Which of the following dilemmas involve the ethical principle of fidelity? Select all that apply.
Correct answer
A,B
Rationale
A: When the nurse is unable to agree with the policies or common practices of an agency.
This situation highlights the ethical principle of fidelity as it involves the nurse's commitment to uphold their professional obligations and values, even when they conflict with agency policies. The nurse's struggle reflects a dedication to patient welfare and ethical standards, demonstrating fidelity to their role as a caregiver.
B: When the nurse is faced with a decision to violate a policy that is harmful to the client.
This option presents a conflict between policy and patient welfare, but it does not directly address the nurse's loyalty or commitment to their ethical duties, which is central to fidelity.
C: When the nurse is certain that clients of different racial and ethnic backgrounds are being treated the same as other clients.
While this option touches on issues of fairness and equality, it does not specifically relate to the nurse's fidelity or obligations to adhere to ethical practices in their role.
D: When the nurse understands that a combative client must be secluded against their will to prevent harm to others.
This option involves a decision made for safety, but it does not focus on the nurse's fidelity to their commitments or ethical principles, as it primarily concerns the application of policy or intervention.
E: When the client refuses to take medication and the nurse respects the client's right to refuse medication.
This scenario emphasizes patient autonomy rather than fidelity. While respecting a client's decision is important, it does not illustrate the nurse's commitment to their ethical duties or obligations.
This situation highlights the ethical principle of fidelity as it involves the nurse's commitment to uphold their professional obligations and values, even when they conflict with agency policies. The nurse's struggle reflects a dedication to patient welfare and ethical standards, demonstrating fidelity to their role as a caregiver.
B: When the nurse is faced with a decision to violate a policy that is harmful to the client.
This option presents a conflict between policy and patient welfare, but it does not directly address the nurse's loyalty or commitment to their ethical duties, which is central to fidelity.
C: When the nurse is certain that clients of different racial and ethnic backgrounds are being treated the same as other clients.
While this option touches on issues of fairness and equality, it does not specifically relate to the nurse's fidelity or obligations to adhere to ethical practices in their role.
D: When the nurse understands that a combative client must be secluded against their will to prevent harm to others.
This option involves a decision made for safety, but it does not focus on the nurse's fidelity to their commitments or ethical principles, as it primarily concerns the application of policy or intervention.
E: When the client refuses to take medication and the nurse respects the client's right to refuse medication.
This scenario emphasizes patient autonomy rather than fidelity. While respecting a client's decision is important, it does not illustrate the nurse's commitment to their ethical duties or obligations.