Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 89%
Testbank
A malpractice lawsuit was filed after a nurse restrained the client for screaming at and attempting to strike anyone who was within striking distance. The nurse followed agency procedures that were consistent with Joint Commission Standards. For which reason is this malpractice lawsuit most likely to be unsuccessful?
Correct answer
B
Rationale
The nurse did not breach duty.
In this scenario, the nurse followed agency procedures that align with Joint Commission Standards, indicating that the nurse acted within the accepted standards of care. By adhering to established protocols for restraint in response to the client's aggressive behavior, the nurse fulfilled their duty to ensure safety, thereby negating a breach of duty.
A: The nurse did not have a duty. The nurse had a duty to protect both the client and others from harm, especially given the client's aggressive behavior, which necessitated intervention.
C: The client did not suffer some type of loss, damage, or injury. While the client may have experienced temporary distress, the focus here is on the nurse's adherence to protocol, not on the client's subjective experience of injury.
D: There was no evidence that a breach of duty was a direct cause of the loss, damage, or injury. Since the nurse did not breach duty by following proper procedures, this option does not apply in this situation.
In this scenario, the nurse followed agency procedures that align with Joint Commission Standards, indicating that the nurse acted within the accepted standards of care. By adhering to established protocols for restraint in response to the client's aggressive behavior, the nurse fulfilled their duty to ensure safety, thereby negating a breach of duty.
A: The nurse did not have a duty. The nurse had a duty to protect both the client and others from harm, especially given the client's aggressive behavior, which necessitated intervention.
C: The client did not suffer some type of loss, damage, or injury. While the client may have experienced temporary distress, the focus here is on the nurse's adherence to protocol, not on the client's subjective experience of injury.
D: There was no evidence that a breach of duty was a direct cause of the loss, damage, or injury. Since the nurse did not breach duty by following proper procedures, this option does not apply in this situation.