Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 91%
Testbank
A client being served in a busy inpatient psychiatric unit becomes very noisy and combative. The other clients are complaining about the noise and are afraid that they will be hurt by the client. The nurse determines that the best course of action for all involved is to seclude the client until the client is able to regain control of his behavior. On which ethical principle did the nurse base this decision?
Correct answer
A
Rationale
Utilitarianism emphasizes the greatest good for the greatest number, which aligns with the nurse's decision to seclude the client to protect the other clients and restore order in the unit.
Utilitarianism is appropriate here as the nurse's action aims to minimize distress and potential harm to the majority of clients by addressing the immediate threat posed by the combative client, thereby promoting overall safety and well-being.
B: Deontology focuses on adherence to rules and duties regardless of outcomes. In this scenario, the nurse's decision prioritizes the overall safety and welfare of all clients rather than strict rule-following.
C: Nonmaleficence emphasizes the obligation to avoid harm. While relevant, the nurse's decision is not solely about avoiding harm but rather maximizing overall safety and well-being in the unit.
D: Veracity pertains to truth-telling and honesty. This principle does not apply to the situation, as the primary concern is not about providing truthful information but about ensuring safety and managing behavior effectively.
Utilitarianism is appropriate here as the nurse's action aims to minimize distress and potential harm to the majority of clients by addressing the immediate threat posed by the combative client, thereby promoting overall safety and well-being.
B: Deontology focuses on adherence to rules and duties regardless of outcomes. In this scenario, the nurse's decision prioritizes the overall safety and welfare of all clients rather than strict rule-following.
C: Nonmaleficence emphasizes the obligation to avoid harm. While relevant, the nurse's decision is not solely about avoiding harm but rather maximizing overall safety and well-being in the unit.
D: Veracity pertains to truth-telling and honesty. This principle does not apply to the situation, as the primary concern is not about providing truthful information but about ensuring safety and managing behavior effectively.