Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 81%
Testbank
A nurse failed to monitor a patient's respiratory status after medicating the patient with a narcotic analgesic. The patient's respiratory status worsened?. The patient's family claimed the nurse committed malpractice. What must be present for the nurse to be held liable?
Correct answer
A,B,C
Rationale
A nurse-patient relationship exists.
For the nurse to be held liable for malpractice, it is essential that a nurse-patient relationship is established. This relationship creates a duty of care, indicating that the nurse has an obligation to monitor and ensure the patient's safety, especially after administering narcotic analgesics that can impair respiratory function.
B: The nurse failed to perform in a reasonable manner. This option does not establish the necessary foundation for liability without first confirming the existence of a nurse-patient relationship, which is crucial for establishing duty.
C: There was harm to the patient. While harm is a component of malpractice, it cannot be considered in isolation; a nurse-patient relationship must first be established to determine if the nurse had a duty to prevent that harm.
D: The nurse was prudent in her performance. This option contradicts the premise of the question, as it suggests that the nurse acted appropriately, which does not support the claim of malpractice in this scenario.
E: The nurse did not cause the patient harm. This option negates the potential for liability because if the nurse did not cause harm, there can be no malpractice claim, regardless of the existence of a nurse-patient relationship.
F: Duty does not exist. This option directly contradicts the requirement for establishing malpractice, as a duty of care arises from the nurse-patient relationship, which is essential for liability to be considered.
For the nurse to be held liable for malpractice, it is essential that a nurse-patient relationship is established. This relationship creates a duty of care, indicating that the nurse has an obligation to monitor and ensure the patient's safety, especially after administering narcotic analgesics that can impair respiratory function.
B: The nurse failed to perform in a reasonable manner. This option does not establish the necessary foundation for liability without first confirming the existence of a nurse-patient relationship, which is crucial for establishing duty.
C: There was harm to the patient. While harm is a component of malpractice, it cannot be considered in isolation; a nurse-patient relationship must first be established to determine if the nurse had a duty to prevent that harm.
D: The nurse was prudent in her performance. This option contradicts the premise of the question, as it suggests that the nurse acted appropriately, which does not support the claim of malpractice in this scenario.
E: The nurse did not cause the patient harm. This option negates the potential for liability because if the nurse did not cause harm, there can be no malpractice claim, regardless of the existence of a nurse-patient relationship.
F: Duty does not exist. This option directly contradicts the requirement for establishing malpractice, as a duty of care arises from the nurse-patient relationship, which is essential for liability to be considered.