Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 62%
Testbank
The nurse must choose between two undesirable alternatives involving a client the nurse is caring for. The client wants to be told about the prognosis, and the family member does not want the client to know. What type of situation is the nurse in?
Correct answer
A
Rationale
An ethical dilemma arises when the nurse must navigate conflicting values between the client's right to know their prognosis and the family's desire to withhold that information. This situation exemplifies an ethical dilemma because it involves moral principles, such as autonomy and beneficence, where the nurse must weigh the client's wishes against the family's concerns.
B: Bioethical dilemma
This option suggests a focus on ethical issues in healthcare practices, but the situation presented is more about personal values and communication between the client and family rather than broader bioethical principles.
C: Value dilemma
While this option implies a conflict of values, it does not encompass the professional ethical responsibilities the nurse faces in balancing the client's autonomy with the family's wishes, which is central to this scenario.
D: Personal dilemma
This choice implies a conflict within the nurse's own beliefs or feelings, but the scenario specifically involves the client's and family's conflicting desires, making it a matter of ethical responsibility rather than a personal conflict.
B: Bioethical dilemma
This option suggests a focus on ethical issues in healthcare practices, but the situation presented is more about personal values and communication between the client and family rather than broader bioethical principles.
C: Value dilemma
While this option implies a conflict of values, it does not encompass the professional ethical responsibilities the nurse faces in balancing the client's autonomy with the family's wishes, which is central to this scenario.
D: Personal dilemma
This choice implies a conflict within the nurse's own beliefs or feelings, but the scenario specifically involves the client's and family's conflicting desires, making it a matter of ethical responsibility rather than a personal conflict.