Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 87%
Testbank
The nurse has a client who is confused and disrupting the unit by screaming obscenities and making a lot of noise. The client has been medicated as prescribed but is not responding to the sedation. The other clients on the unit are reporting agitation. The nurse makes the decision to move the client to a location further down the hall where there are fewer clients. What theory of ethics is the nurse demonstrating?
Correct answer
A
Rationale
Utilitarianism emphasizes actions that maximize overall happiness and minimize harm.
In this scenario, the nurse is prioritizing the well-being of the majority of clients by relocating the disruptive client to reduce noise and agitation on the unit, thereby promoting a more peaceful environment for everyone. This decision aligns with utilitarian principles, as it seeks to achieve the greatest good for the greatest number.
B: Deontology focuses on adherence to rules and duties rather than outcomes. While the nurse has a duty to care for all clients, this approach does not specifically address the need to reduce overall disruption and distress.
C: The idea of rights emphasizes individual entitlements and autonomy. Although the disruptive client has rights, the nurse's decision prioritizes the collective welfare, which is not aligned with a rights-based ethical framework in this context.
D: Obligation of duty centers on the responsibilities of the nurse to provide care. While the nurse has an obligation to care for the disruptive client, the decision made was based on the need to maintain a calm environment for all clients, not solely fulfilling a duty to one individual.
In this scenario, the nurse is prioritizing the well-being of the majority of clients by relocating the disruptive client to reduce noise and agitation on the unit, thereby promoting a more peaceful environment for everyone. This decision aligns with utilitarian principles, as it seeks to achieve the greatest good for the greatest number.
B: Deontology focuses on adherence to rules and duties rather than outcomes. While the nurse has a duty to care for all clients, this approach does not specifically address the need to reduce overall disruption and distress.
C: The idea of rights emphasizes individual entitlements and autonomy. Although the disruptive client has rights, the nurse's decision prioritizes the collective welfare, which is not aligned with a rights-based ethical framework in this context.
D: Obligation of duty centers on the responsibilities of the nurse to provide care. While the nurse has an obligation to care for the disruptive client, the decision made was based on the need to maintain a calm environment for all clients, not solely fulfilling a duty to one individual.