Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 94%
Testbank
A patient expresses fears about her upcoming surgery. The nurse responds, 'You really don't have to worry. You have a great doctor and everything will turn out fine.' Why is this statement a barrier to communication?
Correct answer
A,C
Rationale
A: It diminishes the patient's concerns.
This response minimizes the patient's fears by suggesting that they are unfounded, which can lead the patient to feel invalidated. Acknowledging and exploring the patient's concerns is essential for effective communication and emotional support, rather than dismissing them with reassurances.
B: It is not a complete answer, the nurse should provide more information.
While providing additional information can be beneficial, the primary issue here is the dismissal of the patient's feelings, which undermines the emotional aspect of communication rather than just the informational content.
C: It is equivalent to telling the patient to not talk about her fears.
Although the nurse's response may imply that the patient should not express her fears, it primarily serves to diminish those fears instead of outright silencing the patient, making this option less relevant to the core issue.
D: Providing reassurance is not therapeutic.
While reassurance can sometimes be unhelpful, the key problem in this scenario is that it diminishes the patient's concerns rather than the act of reassurance itself. Thus, this option does not address the main barrier to communication.
This response minimizes the patient's fears by suggesting that they are unfounded, which can lead the patient to feel invalidated. Acknowledging and exploring the patient's concerns is essential for effective communication and emotional support, rather than dismissing them with reassurances.
B: It is not a complete answer, the nurse should provide more information.
While providing additional information can be beneficial, the primary issue here is the dismissal of the patient's feelings, which undermines the emotional aspect of communication rather than just the informational content.
C: It is equivalent to telling the patient to not talk about her fears.
Although the nurse's response may imply that the patient should not express her fears, it primarily serves to diminish those fears instead of outright silencing the patient, making this option less relevant to the core issue.
D: Providing reassurance is not therapeutic.
While reassurance can sometimes be unhelpful, the key problem in this scenario is that it diminishes the patient's concerns rather than the act of reassurance itself. Thus, this option does not address the main barrier to communication.