Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 94%
Testbank
Your patient has been newly diagnosed with AIDS. You are good friends with the patient's wife and feel that you should tell her so that she can be tested. Which of the following statement(s) is(are) true?
Correct answer
C,D
Rationale
C: The patient must give permission for the AIDS test results to be disclosed to the wife.
This option is correct because patient confidentiality is a fundamental principle in healthcare. According to HIPAA regulations, healthcare providers must obtain explicit consent from the patient before sharing any health information with family members, including spouses, regardless of their relationship to the patient.
A: Because the wife is considered an immediate family member, it is permissible for you to discuss the patient's test results with her.
This statement fails because being an immediate family member does not grant automatic access to a patient's medical information without their consent.
B: Failure to disclose the serious diagnosis to the wife could be considered negligence.
This option is flawed as it misinterprets the legal obligation to maintain patient confidentiality. Negligence would not apply here since the patient’s privacy must be respected.
D: Discussing the test results without the patient's permission is a breach of HIPAA.
While this statement is partially true, it inaccurately suggests that the primary concern is a breach of HIPAA rather than the necessity of obtaining patient consent before disclosure.
This option is correct because patient confidentiality is a fundamental principle in healthcare. According to HIPAA regulations, healthcare providers must obtain explicit consent from the patient before sharing any health information with family members, including spouses, regardless of their relationship to the patient.
A: Because the wife is considered an immediate family member, it is permissible for you to discuss the patient's test results with her.
This statement fails because being an immediate family member does not grant automatic access to a patient's medical information without their consent.
B: Failure to disclose the serious diagnosis to the wife could be considered negligence.
This option is flawed as it misinterprets the legal obligation to maintain patient confidentiality. Negligence would not apply here since the patient’s privacy must be respected.
D: Discussing the test results without the patient's permission is a breach of HIPAA.
While this statement is partially true, it inaccurately suggests that the primary concern is a breach of HIPAA rather than the necessity of obtaining patient consent before disclosure.