Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 79%
Testbank
An older adult who has had multiple strokes is refusing artificial nutrition and hydration against medical advice and in opposition to their daughter. The patient's nurse advocates for the patient, stating which party is the most appropriate decision maker?
Correct answer
A
Rationale
A: Patient
The patient is the most appropriate decision maker in this situation, as they have the right to refuse treatment, including artificial nutrition and hydration, even if it goes against medical advice or family wishes.
B: Patient's daughter
The daughter cannot make decisions on behalf of the patient if the patient is competent to express their wishes, as the patient's autonomy takes precedence in healthcare decisions.
C: Health care provider
The health care provider's role is to offer medical advice and support, but they cannot override the patient's right to refuse treatment, making them an inappropriate decision maker in this scenario.
D: Ethics consult team
While the ethics consult team can provide guidance on complex cases, they do not have the authority to make decisions for the patient, especially when the patient is capable of expressing their own preferences.
The patient is the most appropriate decision maker in this situation, as they have the right to refuse treatment, including artificial nutrition and hydration, even if it goes against medical advice or family wishes.
B: Patient's daughter
The daughter cannot make decisions on behalf of the patient if the patient is competent to express their wishes, as the patient's autonomy takes precedence in healthcare decisions.
C: Health care provider
The health care provider's role is to offer medical advice and support, but they cannot override the patient's right to refuse treatment, making them an inappropriate decision maker in this scenario.
D: Ethics consult team
While the ethics consult team can provide guidance on complex cases, they do not have the authority to make decisions for the patient, especially when the patient is capable of expressing their own preferences.