Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 87%
Testbank
Which of the following is an example of paternalistic behavior?
Correct answer
B
Rationale
Intercepting a visitor's gift of candy to a patient with diabetes exemplifies paternalistic behavior by prioritizing the patient's health over their autonomy.
This action reflects a paternalistic approach as it involves making a decision on behalf of the patient, assuming that the caregiver knows what is best for them without considering the patient's wishes or ability to make their own choices regarding their diet.
A: Telling a patient that a painful procedure will not hurt misrepresents the truth and can undermine trust, but it does not involve overriding the patient's autonomy in the same way as paternalistic behavior.
C: Deciding to close the intensive care unit when all beds are full represents a systemic decision based on resource allocation rather than individual patient autonomy, thus it does not reflect paternalistic behavior towards a specific patient.
D: Discussing a patient's condition with the patient's roommate breaches confidentiality and respect for privacy, but it does not exemplify paternalism since it does not involve making decisions on behalf of the patient.
This action reflects a paternalistic approach as it involves making a decision on behalf of the patient, assuming that the caregiver knows what is best for them without considering the patient's wishes or ability to make their own choices regarding their diet.
A: Telling a patient that a painful procedure will not hurt misrepresents the truth and can undermine trust, but it does not involve overriding the patient's autonomy in the same way as paternalistic behavior.
C: Deciding to close the intensive care unit when all beds are full represents a systemic decision based on resource allocation rather than individual patient autonomy, thus it does not reflect paternalistic behavior towards a specific patient.
D: Discussing a patient's condition with the patient's roommate breaches confidentiality and respect for privacy, but it does not exemplify paternalism since it does not involve making decisions on behalf of the patient.