Difficulty: Medium
Average Score: 84%
Testbank
A patient nearing the end of life requests that he be given no food or fluids. The physician orders the insertion of a nasogastric tube to feed the patient. What situation does this create for the nurse providing care?
Correct answer
C
Rationale
An ethical dilemma about inconsistent courses of action arises in this situation. The patient's request for no food or fluids conflicts with the physician's order to insert a nasogastric tube for feeding, creating a moral conflict for the nurse between respecting the patient's autonomy and following medical directives.
A: nurse must follow the physician's orders. This option fails because blindly adhering to the physician's orders overlooks the patient's expressed wishes, which are crucial in end-of-life care decisions.
B: an inability to provide care for the patient. This choice does not apply, as the nurse can still provide care; however, the care being provided may not align with the patient's desires, leading to ethical concerns.
D: a barrier to establishing an effective nurse-patient relationship. While there may be tension, this option does not capture the core issue of conflicting ethical responsibilities, which is central to the dilemma.
A: nurse must follow the physician's orders. This option fails because blindly adhering to the physician's orders overlooks the patient's expressed wishes, which are crucial in end-of-life care decisions.
B: an inability to provide care for the patient. This choice does not apply, as the nurse can still provide care; however, the care being provided may not align with the patient's desires, leading to ethical concerns.
D: a barrier to establishing an effective nurse-patient relationship. While there may be tension, this option does not capture the core issue of conflicting ethical responsibilities, which is central to the dilemma.